Imp-Chan wrote:
I'm not saying it's impossible to improve ourselves through hard work (except that sometimes our bodies dictate that we can't... for example all the hard work in the world won't keep you from getting diabetes or bipolar disorder), but I am saying that it is perfectly reasonable to presuppose that one race of beings would be naturally stronger than another, or better at magic, or less likely to age simply because they lucked out genetically... Our experience demonstrates this amply already even within just familial lines.-_-'
There are biological and actuarial factors involved. The elves are perpetually youthful. This means that, however much they look and sound like homo sapiens, their tissues, hormones, etc., aren't operating exactly like ours. They are constantly expending energy (natural or magical) to prevent the incremental tissue degeneration that humans accept as the natural process of aging. That should mean that they heal faster and have greater reserves of energy that could be channeled into, say feats of prodigious strength and speed.
Another good reason why they would be superior: beating the odds. If you took a population of, say, 1000 humans, and put them in a fixed environment (enchanted forest, hidden city, "closed community," Stepford suburbs, whatever) there is going to be a death rate, albeit a small one, from accidents and natural events. Things like fire, flood, falling down stairs, falling trees, etc.) If you set a rate of "death by misadventure" at 5% over fifty years, then upgrade the population from an adult lifespan of 5 decades to 100 decades, the odds on there being any number of elves in the 2000 or 3000 year clubs are fairly small. Morever, there has to be birth rate of 5% per 50 yrs to keep up the population, even without wars.
If you're going to postulate a community of elves all over a millenium old and births every 200 yrs or so, they have to be far faster, smarter, and stronger than humans just to survive the centuries.
Of course, slaughtering catgirls at the current rate may well wipe out
that species.